Hoaxers

One of the most interesting reactions to the book has been to do with crop-circles. Geoff Ward, of the West Country Western Daily Press, is interested in these mysterious formations. I think he has been for some time judging by the circle he has printed on the banner at the top of his column. Having read In Search of the English Eccentric he turned detective, beginning his weekly newsletter with the following:

SOMEWHERE in Wiltshire, in a wheatfield under a brilliant full moon, author Henry Hemming found himself helping to make a crop circle. Silhouetted against the crop, seven men with stomping boards and measuring tapes went about their business in earnest. Several hours later, the job was done, and the group could relax and speculate on how the crop-circle community would react when daylight came. Henry, researching his book In Search of the English Eccentric, just out, had encountered Britain ’s leading crop-circle maker John Lundberg, who allowed the writer to join his party on condition that he never revealed the location of the formation created that night. Lundberg never reveals the locations of any crop circles he makes, which undermines his claims somewhat.

Now, the universe may be infinite, but my Mysterious West page in the Western Daily Press unfortunately is not. So I am including in this new sletter a little piece of detective work which I have carried out - I believe I can identify the Hemming/Lundberg crop formation. In his book, Hemming describes a visit by himself and Lundberg to the Crop Circle Connector get-together in the Coronation Hall at Alton Barnes on August 1 last year. Henry tells his readers that he helped to make the crop circle some weeks before - under that full moon, which he describes as being so bright it was "like a floodlight". Now, in this case, the only relevant full moons were on June 1 and June 30 - a “blue moon” month, having two full moons in it. The full moon on July 30 was obviously too close to the Crop Circle Connector event. I rule out June 30 as no crop circles appeared in Wiltshire immediately after the date. But, referring to Steve and Karen Alexander’s Crop Circle Year Book for 2007, I see that a formation did appear on June 3 in the famous East Field at Alton Barnes. This was a three-armed propeller-like pattern with five circles on each arm. As crop circles go, it was not a particularly elaborate design. The Hemming/Lundberg team could therefore have created this formation overnight on June 1 or June 2, when the full moon was at its peak. I rest my case.

Ward's rationale was sound, but as one of the few conditions for joining Lundberg that night was to keep the location a secret. So to either confirm or dispel this hypothesis would of course fly in the face of that. I wrote back to Geoff explaining this. Several days later he published the following:

ON THE TRAIL OF THE HOAXERS
27 June 2008

Reading between the lines, it seems I was right about the location of the crop circle created a year ago by author Henry Hemming and John Lundberg, who is regarded as Britain's leading crop-circle creator.

From unwitting clues in Henry's new book, In Search of the English Eccentric, featured on this page last week, I deduced that the formation was the one found in the East Field, Alton Barnes, on June 3 last year.

I was interested to pursue this because Lundberg never reveals the locations of any crop circles he makes, apart from those done purely for commercial concerns.

My piece of sleuthing went out on my Mysterious West email newsletter to regular readers last week.

Henry's response was: "That was very interesting what you put together. It's extremely frustrating not being able to say yes or no to your hypothesis, but I'm fascinated by what you've put together."

Enough said.

In researching his book, Henry was allowed to join Lundberg's party on condition he never revealed the location of the formation he helped to create.

And I never will. But all is not as it seems in the mysterious west. Nor the mysterious east. When writing Misdaventure in the Middle East time and again I was compelled to change not just the identity of a man or woman who had said something politically subversive, but also parts of their physical appearance, or the location of where we met. It's rarely enough to omit details. Often it's necessary to alter certain descriptive elements in order to create an effective mask.